When the the Mai-Kai opened on the outskirts of Fort Lauderdale in 1956, the Polynesian restaurant quickly set a new standard for Tiki cocktails, earning fame for its reverential and original creations featuring fresh ingredients and perfectly balanced rum blends. This legacy continued for decades, even through a catastrophic back-of-house roof collapse that forced a four-year closing in late 2020.
A $20 million restoration engineered by a new ownership group led by historic preservationist Bill Fuller not only returned the vintage property and its cocktails to their high standards, it also gave the Mai-Kai the opportunity to create something most elite bar programs have never done.
To honor the legacy of the Mai-Kai and its cocktails, Fuller and his team sought to create their own heritage rum blend to bring authenticity to the iconic drinks the founders created. Years in the making, the result is Mai-Kai Old Style Special Rum No. 1, created in the Caribbean and bottled exclusively for use (and sale) at the South Florida restaurant. New cocktail recipes below: Daiquiri No. 1 | Hammerhead Bite
The rum was released in November 2025, one year after the grand reopening. The road to the rum’s creation is long and winding, and the story is richly detailed. We’ll save that for a future blog post, but until then we’d like to share all the information you’ll need to appreciate this special spirit. The following FAQ was prepared in cooperation with the Mai-Kai and the rum’s marketing company, Roneros Rum Brand Makers.
Beverage director Cory Starr serves samples of Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 during the release party on Nov. 28. A special display was created for the gift shop. (Photos by Hurricane Hayward)
What is Mai-Kai Rum No. 1, aka Mai-Kai Old Style Special Rum Number 1?
A crafted, authentic blend in a mid-century style used to create the Mai-Kai’s cocktails by Mariano Licudine, master mixologist from 1956 to 1979. Dozens of his secret recipes are still featured at the restaurant today. Previous historic antecedents include the Dagger and Appleton punch rums. For more on those rums, check out this Atomic Grog story (last updated in 2021).
Hurricane Hayward shows off the Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 display in the gift shop, right next to the window into the historic back service bar. (Atomic Grog photo, February 2026)
Where can I buy it?
It’s available exclusively in the Mai-Kai Trading Company gift shop, which is open daily during restaurant hours. If you’re making a special trip to buy the rum, you can tell the valet. Check MaiKai.com and our related Mai-Kai FAQ for details.
How much does it cost?
You’ll pay $75 for a 1-liter bottle, $400 for a case of six.
Is this a limited release?
No, it will continue to be available for purchase and featured in cocktails at the Mai-Kai.
Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 is equally enjoyable served neat, or in cocktails such as the new Aloha Old Fashioned. (Photo by Hurricane Hayward, December 2025)
Is it a “sipping” or “mixing” rum?
Both. While designed as the perfect mixing rum in Mai-Kai cocktails, the complex blend is also accessible as a sipper and should appeal to fans of both.
The Mai-Kai’s general manager and beverage director, Cory Starr, introduced Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 during a Miami Rum Festival seminar (left) on Nov. 8. The next day, he was joined by Molokai Bar server Hannah Almanzar in serving up samples during the event’s grand tasting. (Photos by Hurricane Hayward)
Look for full coverage of the presentation hosted by ambassador Adrienne Stoner of Maison Ferrand in an upcoming deep dive into the 100-proof blend, which is being produced exclusively for the Mai-Kai. The quick answer to the burning question: Sorry, there is currently no plan for distribution outside of the Mai-Kai Trading Company gift shop.
It’s a unique rum that bypasses normal distribution, sent directly to the restaurant from the Caribbean via a bottling plant in southwest Florida. The blend of rums from historic stills in Barbados and Jamaica was a unanimous hit at the Coral Gables festival, including the main grand tasting event on Sunday, Nov. 9.
This story will offer a quick recap of the festival and look ahead at the upcoming release. But that’s not all. Starr gave us the exclusive inside scoop on many other exciting plans for the Mai-Kai during the 2025 holidays, plus more to come in 2026.
Special menu, early shows welcome Thanksgiving diners
The Mai-Kai will offer a special holiday dinner and show on Thanksgiving Day with two seatings: 2 p.m. (show at 3:30) and 5 p.m. (show at 6:30). The bars open at 1 p.m. with happy hour running from 4 until 7, offering most cocktails priced at 50% off.
A special dinner menu is available, along with the full regular menu. Thanksgiving meals include a choice of three appetizers, entrees and desserts for $75. Main courses are Huli Huli BBQ Turkey, Palm Sugar Salmon, and Kalua Roast Pork. [See the menu online]
If you want to attend the dinner show, it must be booked separately online through the official website. Tables are filling up fast, so make your reservations now.
Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 set for Black Friday release
After shopping yourself ragged in search of holiday gifts, treat yourself (or the special rum lover in your life) to a very special present on Friday, Nov. 28. During the release party that begins at 5 p.m. in both the Molokai and Bora Bora bars, you’ll be among the first to be able to pick up a bottle (or more) of Mai-Kai Old Style Special Rum Number One.
The rum will be priced at $75 for an embossed one-liter bottle in a custom box, both featuring distinctive Mai-Kai imagery. It will also be available by the case (six bottles) for $400, Starr said. The gift shop will also have some special exclusive merch and offers available during the party.
Also look for a special menu of Rum No. 1 cocktails at the event, including a flight of classics.These may include the Mai Tai and Zombie, which were served at the Nov. 6 sneak preview event.
In addition to the cocktail flight, you will be able to buy small samples of the rum at the bar to try it out. A new sipping rum menu is in the works. Starr said he’s been collecting rums since he joined the team as beverage director before the reopening last year. The rum list, which will likely be paired with the after-dinner drinks and desserts on a combined menu, will favor quality over quantity, Starr said. “We’re going to start with around 50, then get to 100 at some point.”
Beverage director Cory Starr pours cocktails and serves samples of Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 during a sneak preview event in the Molokai Bar on Nov. 6. (Photos by Hurricane Hayward)
Like other Fridays this month, the 28th will also include live music in the Molokai Bar with Smerks and the Night Mares performing from 5:30 to 9:30 p.m. Makani Ryel will entertain Bor Bora Bar guests starting at 5 p.m..
The Miami Rum Festival offered guests a unique chance to learn about (and taste) Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 at a Nov. 8 seminar at the Coral Gables Marriott hosted by Adrienne Stoner, an ambassador for Maison Ferrand and all of its brands. The French company also owns the West Indies Rum Distillery in Barbados, where the Mai-Kai rum is blended and shipped to Florida. A portion of the blend also includes rum from historic pot stills at the Long Pond Distillery in Jamaica, where Maison Ferrand shares ownership.
Stoner gave us an inside peek at both distilleries and profiled some of the key members of the team who craft the rums. She broke down the historic stills and some of the key components in Rum No. 1, most notably JAWS – a unique, high-ester rum sourced from the historic Vulcan pot still that dates back to the 19th century.
Beverage director Cory Starr (left) and Maison Ferrand ambassador Adrienne Stoner discuss Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 during a seminar at the Miami Rum Renaissance Festival on Nov. 8. (Photo by Hurricane Hayward)
We enjoyed a neat sip along with Starr’s updated version of the Mai-Kai’s Planters Punch as Stoner explained the rum’s creation and distillation process in Barbados. We also tasted a 120-proof sample of the JAWS rum, which is considered to be the first long fermentation, high-ester rum component crafted in Barbados in the past 80 years. You can clearly see how this is the key element in the Mai-Kai blend.
On Nov. 9, the festival hosted dozens of rum brands, including the Mai-Kai, for more than four hours of tastings at the historic Coral Gables Woman’s Club. Starr was joined by Mai-Kai manager Salomé Sepulveda and Molokai Bar server Hannah Almanzar in greeting guests and serving samples in their colorfully branded booth. They also passed out Starr’s reconfigured version of the Mai-Kai’s classic Bora Bora cocktail featuring the new rum.
Right next door was a booth from Roneros Rum Brand Makers, the firm that developed the Mai-Kai rum’s distinctive branding, packaging and marketing. This includes the new MaiKaiRum.com website, which features the story behind the rum as well as more than a dozen cocktail recipes you can try after you pick up a bottle. If you’re feeling crafty, you can even submit your own.
Bar manager Michael DeMahy makes the Bora Bora and Zombie cocktails using Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 at the Nov. 6 sneak preview event in the Molokai Bar. (Photos by Hurricane Hayward)
Lucky attendees at the Nov. 6 sneak preview in the Molokai Bar got a head start and were able to take a bottle home when Starr released a small batch for purchase. Some 30 or so guests were treated to samples of Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 plus four different Mai-Kai cocktails, shaken up to order in the “poop deck” area of the bar by Starr and bar manager Michael DeMahy. It was a rare chance to see these two master mixologists in action close-up in the Molokai, where drinks are usually made in secret in the back bar.
Two of the cocktails – the Planters Punch and Bora Bora – are reconfigured versions of classics featuring a full serving of the new rum. Both are noticeable improvements that will likely find their way onto the permanent menu in their reimagined form. Those who tasted them raved about both.
The two others we tasted, the Mai Tai and Zombie, were also excellent versions featuring a hefty dose of the new 100-proof rum. These two “No. 1 versions” will likely remain special menu items, Starr said, served in addition to the classic variations that feature blends of multiple rums and are tried-and-true favorites.
This won’t be the case for every cocktail, but Starr promised other off-menu drinks featuring the new rum. Deciding which drinks get which treatment is still a work in progress. Most cocktails that were designed to include a “dark Jamaican” style rum will simply be updated to include the new rum instead of the Mai-Kai’s previous blend that has been in use since the Kohala Bay brand stopped production in 2017.
The rum will be stealthily added, and Starr noted that the intention is that it goes undetected to most guests. “We’ll roll them out, but I don’t know when,” he said. “It’s more like a secret kind of rollout so people don’t really notice it happening. It’s going to be kind of a slow change.”
The Mai-Kai has long sought a proper replacement for Kohala Bay, and now thanks to the new ownership team and managing partner Bill Fuller, it has become a reality.
12 Drinks of Christmas, limited-edition mug highlight jolly holidays
The Mai-Kai has not leaned into the holidays in a big way since 2019, when it introduced its first lineup of Christmas drinks to pair with festive but tasteful decor. In the years since, the thirst for Christmas pop-up bars has grown exponentially.
Last year’s holidays came too quick after the reopening, but Starr and bar manager Michael DeMahy have an ambitious lineup of themed cocktails planned for 2025. Dubbed the “12 Drinks of Christmas,” these limited-time cocktails will be split among menus in the Molokai and Bora Bora bars, plus the showroom. This is even more than we enjoyed during the recent month of Hulaween hijinx.
The Christmas Rum Barrel Mug was created for the Mai-Kai by John Mulder of Eeekum Bookum. (Official photo)
Similar to Halloween, it will be a month-long celebration that Starr said they hope to kick off on Monday, Dec. 1. Be sure to mark your calendar for Wednesday, Dec. 3, when a special holiday mug will be introduced at an event attended by its creator. Doors open at 4 p.m.
Starr tapped a noted Florida mug designer, John Mulder of Eeekum Bookum in St. Petersburg, to craft and produce a special limited edition Christmas Rum Barrel Mug.
You can buy the mug in the gift shop for $125, but it’s a limited run of 250, so don’t delay. There will be two versions: A very limited 50 green and white barrels, and 200 of a more traditional brown Barrel, Starr said. There is a limit of one mug per person when you shop in the Mai-Kai Trading Post.
Master of ceremonies Lono and members of the Mai-Kai’s Polynesian Islander Revue. (Mai-Kai photo, January 2025)
Performers from the past to return for anniversary events
The events will include a reunion of past performers from the Polynesian Islander Revue, which dates back to 1961 and has long been considered the longest running authentic South Seas stage show in the United States. The driving force of the troupe for more than five decades was Mai-Kai matriarch Mireille Thornton, who joined the restaurant’s original show in the early 1960s and went on to become not only its choreographer and spiritual leader, but eventual owner of the restaurant. She married owner Bob Thornton, assuming leadership of the family empire when he passed away in 1989.
Mireille Thornton was a dancer and choreographer of the Mai-Kai’s Polynesian Islander Revue from the early 1960s through 2020. (Mai-Kai photo)
Two of her children ran the day-to-day operations, but it was “Mrs. T,” as she’s lovingly known, who eventually saved the Mai-Kai when she signed off on the sale to historic preservationist Bill Fuller of Barlington Group in September 2021. [Past coverage] Now in her 80s and retired to north Florida, the native of Tahiti consulted on the revival of the stage show she led for more than 50 years when it returned in November 2024. [See video]
The performances are now being guided by longtime emcee Lono, who has taken over as Polynesian cultural director after the departure of Teuruhei Kalaniu’i Buchin in August. We’re told that Lono, who started with the Mai-Kai in 2009 and spent a decade under Thornton’s wing, is working on plans to bring back some of the classic show elements, though we may not see those changes until 2026.
Many of the show’s original members and backing band were accomplished performers in the South Pacific. Now, more than 60 years later, the Mai-Kai has its own cultural legacy.
Multiple members of the troupe have been there for decades, and several are second and third generation Mai-Kai. Dancer Varua (aka Nicholas Mattei) is the son of longtime manager Kern Mattei. His grandmother was in the show and his mother was a Molokai Girl. [See video] Michael, the AV director and Lono’s assistant, is Mireille Thornton’s grandson.
With this spirit of ‘ohana (or family) in mind, the Mai-Kai is inviting back many past performers for the anniversary weekend. You’ll even be able to see some of them perform on stage during the Saturday dinner shows. The formal anniversary celebration Sunday. Starr teased other additions to the weekend, including bands in the Molokai and Bora Bora bars.
A new event center is being built on the other side of this wall along the back corridor in the Mai-Kai’s outdoor garden. (Photo by Hurricane Hayward, May 2025)
New event center will complete Mai-Kai reimagination in 2026
Last but not least, Starr confirmed that preliminary work has begun on a new event center that will occupy back-of-house space adjacent to the kitchen that was formerly used for storage. When asked if it’s moving forward, he replied: “It definitely is.”
This large multi-purpose space will be available for a wide range of special events, from weddings and reunions, to corporate meetings, to music and social events such as The Hukilau. The plans for this addition were approved along with all of the Phase 1 enhancements back in 2022, but this part of the project was put on hold to expedite the November 2024 reopening. Related coverage:The Hukilau returns to the Mai-Kai for five days of Tiki festivities
The Mai-Kai’s new event center will be accessed via a door in the old Chinese oven room, which has been reimagined by creative director “Typhoon Tommy” Allsmiller. The lettering was salvaged from the outside of the building. (Photos by Hurricane Hayward, February-March 2025)
The public will access the event center via a door in the renovated room that used to house the kitchen’s Chinese ovens. This area was redesigned by creative director “Typhoon Tommy” Allsmiller with a lavish Chinese theme to match the building and surrounding area. The outside of the building, which appears dilapidated but is actually a clever feat of themed design, features a new Chinese saying across the top after the old lettering was moved inside. [Previous coverage]
• Spike’s Breezeway:Watch a video tour with Typhoon Tommy
This room is accessible both via the dining rooms and the outdoor garden. The plan also calls for the new corridor in the southwest corner of the garden to feature a door into the event center. This large area can also be used for the events.
The back-of-house area that contained the large storage room and massive 1970s-era kitchen remains without a roof after the October 2020 collapse that precipitated the Mai-Kai’s closing, sale and $20 million restoration. A new, smaller kitchen was built in old offices and other spaces that survived the roof collapse. Additional temporary kitchen structures were added to the open space in order for the restaurant to serve its thousands of loyal guests when it reopened last November.
Plans presented during a city of Oakland Park online meeting in 2022 show the future event center (left) and kitchen highlighted by managing partner Bill Fuller. The area in blue is the current bar and kitchen.
But now, after chef Justin Sherrer took over in March, the Mai-Kai is preparing for a change. The Phase 2 project includes a reconfiguration of the kitchen, as detailed in an earlier report. Some of the temporary buildings will be removed, and it’s possible the old Chinese ovens will return in some form.
The plans have changed slightly since Allsmiller’s original 2022 designs for a large, enclosed A-frame structure. [See 2022 coverage] It will remain a large A-frame, but we’re told it’s probably going to be more of an indoor-outdoor space, not unlike the new Bora Bora Bar under the old entry porte-cochère. [Past coverage]
“It’s not exactly the same, but it’s in the same vein,” Starr said. As for an opening timeframe, he said they’re planning for it to be available in 2026. “It will be done as soon as we can,” he said.
Mai-Kai Rum No. 1 to make a splash during 2025 Miami Rum Renaissance Festival
There will be multiple ways to enjoy the long-awaited signature rum as part of the 16th annual Miami Rum Festival. Enjoy a sneak preview Thursday at the Mai-Kai, learn more at Saturday’s seminar day in Miami, then sip along with hundreds of other spirits at Sunday’s Grand Tasting.
Mai-Kai’s Hulaween party returns from the dead in 2025
The historic restaurant was transformed into a haunted Polynesian island during October, culminating with the 13th Hulaween party on Oct. 31 in the Molokai and Bora Bars.
Mai-Kai October update: Hulaween returns bigger than ever, new food menu debuts
Halloween revelry and artistic decor have engulfed the historic South Florida restaurant all month with multiple special events. Check out the full preview, plus a recap of all the past happenings and a detailed look at the new food menu, plus more.
Halloween cocktails invade the Mai-Kai for October
Featuring fire, smoke and detailed theming, the new drinks capture the spirit of the season. Check out our ratings and reviews of these scary offerings, plus other recent special cocktails.
EXCLUSIVE:Mai-Kai Restoration & Reopening Guide
Check out all past news, photos, video and deep details on the refurbishment and resurrection of the Polynesian palace.
You know the summer event season is underway when The Hukilau blows through South Florida in early June, serving up a whirlwind weekend of live music, expert symposiums, pool parties, vendors, and cocktails crafted by notable bartenders from around the world. As a bonus this year, hundreds of Hukilau passholders were invited to attend an event inside freshly renovated spaces of the historic Mai-Kai restaurant for the first time in five years. RELATED:The Hukilau 2024 live coverage, photos and video from social media
A power trio of authors at The Hukilau 2024 (from left): Matt Pietrek, David Wondrich and Jeff “Beachbum” Berry. (Photo by Hurricane Hayward / June 8, 2024)
The Hukilau 2024 – June 6-9 at the Beachcomber Resort & Club in Pompano Beach. Featuring live music (Messer Chups, Surfer Joe, L’Exotighost, Slowey and the Boats, Lords of Atlantis, The Intoxicators, The Disasternauts, The Mermers, Skinny Jimmy Stingray), symposiums and classes (Jeff “Beachbum” Berry, Ian “Rum Ambassador” Burrell, David Wondrich, Matt Pietrek, Daniele Dalla Pola, Spike Marble, Marie King, Lucky Munro), 20+ guest cocktail bars, pool parties, Tiki Treasures Bazaar, plus more.
• The Hukilau on social media: Instagram | Facebook page and group
The location is also hard to beat. While South Florida’s heat and humidity can be stifling at this time of year, the location of a boutique hotel directly on the Atlantic Ocean with its gentle breezes and beachfront access makes up for that. The Hukilau takes over the entire 140-room Beachcomber Resort for three nights and parts of four days, meaning the immersion in a tropical paradise is complete. Attendees spill over into other beachfront hotels, and classes were also held this year in a nearby event space.
After more than 20 years (this was the 21st live event in South Florida and 22nd overall), event attendees (known as “villagers”) know what to expect with the weather. Sporadic showers are welcome to cool things off, but this year was even hotter than usual, averaging around 90 in the day and 78 in the evening. Many activities are held outdoors, which can be a challenge.
The Hukilau’s Saturday’s pool party at the Beachcomber Resort. (Photo by Hurricane Hayward / June 8, 2024)
But the resort’s pools and shaded areas, not to mention all the cool beverages, gave guests ample ways to beat the heat. Other than an early Saturday storm, the event was free of rain and nobody seemed to mind the challenges Mother Nature presented. Like Tiki itself, the event was the perfect escape from the daily grind.
As detailed in our full preview in March, the lineup of bands performing this year had an unprecedented global flair. Surf and exotica groups dominated, and musicians hailing from Russia, Spain, Italy and around the United States made the trek to perform on the main poolside stage as well as several other spots around the Beachcomber property.
The performances lived up to the hype and anticipation with all the bands delivering top-notch sets, from the Mermers on Thursday night to the Saturday night headlining hijinx of The Disasternauts. Saturday’s early afternoon rain slowed the momentum but couldn’t stop the party. Slowey and the Boats shifted to an evening set under the courtyard tent, where they also played Friday night to give the bungalow parties a perfect laid-back soundtrack. They also performed poolside on Friday afternoon.
Russia’s Messer Chups enjoy their debut set at The Hukilau on Friday night. (Photo by Hurricane Hayward / June 7, 2024)
Messer Chups, L’Exotighost and Lords of Atlantis all played The Hukilau for the first time, while Surfer Joe made his second appearance. They peformed on the main stage both Friday and Saturday, allowing villagers more opportunity to catch these rare treats. Hukilau stalwarts The Intoxicators also played twice, headlining Thursday night under the South Tiki Hut and returning for a blistering afternoon set poolside on Saturday. And don’t forget local guitar slinger Skinny Jimmy Stingray, who kicked off Saturday’s party on the main stage.
Below you’ll find photos of all the bands presented in chronological order. We also captured six of the nine bands on video. You can watch the full song clips below, or click here and bookmark our Hukilau 2024 playlist on YouTube for future enjoyment.
Returning to The Hukilau seven years after their 2017 debut, The Mermers bought tons of talent and creativity to their set of instrumental alternative surf and exotica. The foursome from Gainesville, Fla., has two albums to its credit and performs extensively across the region.
The Mermers open The Hukilau’s Thursday night festivities under the South Tiki Hut. (Photo by Hurricane Hayward / June 6, 2024)
Hailing from Madrid, Spain, L’Exotighost brought a new spin on classic exotica to The Hukilau with a distinctive style that employed guitar, drums and bass ukulele, plus vibraphone, theremin and other exotic sounds. The four-piece band’s poolside sets Friday and Saturday featured songs from its latest album, Kamongo (2022), available on Hi-Tide Recordings.
L’Exotighost performs Friday afternoon on The Hukilau’s main stage. (Photo by Hurricane Hayward / June 7, 2024)
Tiki fans packed a conference room early on the first day of Inuhele: Atlanta’s Tiki Weekend on Jan. 20, eager to hear and see details of the upcoming multimillion-dollar refurbishments planned for the historic Mai-Kai restaurant in South Florida. The Atomic Grog was happy to oblige, presenting exclusive photos, renderings and video of the project that is poised to shift into high gear in the coming months.
Hurricane Hayward kicks off his presentation, “Okole Maluna! The Return of The Mai-Kai,” at Inuhele in Atlanta on Jan. 20, 2023. (Photo by Tim Glazner)
Jim “Hurricane” Hayward sprinkled the presentation on the 225-seat room’s large screen with new images and architectural plans. Appearing via pre-recorded video, creative director “Typhoon Tommy” Allsmiller took viewers on 10-minute walk-through of his work in The Molokai bar, one of the restaurant’s oldest dining rooms, plus a stroll through the gardens. The video received a great response after the interior designer and craftsman urged attendees to enjoy their Mai-Kai cocktails after the presentation.
Other upcoming projects were detailed for the first time, including new Mai-Kai mugs and other merchandise by contemporary Tiki artists, plus a signature rum blend from two historic Caribbean distilleries. After digesting all the news, the approximately 175 guests were invited to quench their thirst with authentic Mai-Kai cocktails in a poolside VIP lounge for a meet-and-greet event.
The fourth Inuhele event was held Jan. 20-22 at the Atlanta Sheraton Downtown, just two blocks from the historic Trader Vic’s location, where many attendees paid a nightly pilgrimage. Highlights included a wide array of presentations all three days, an authentic luau, rocking live bands, a marketplace featuring many top artists and craftspeople, daily room parties and special events, plus more. Check out our event preview for an overview of the diversity and creativity of Inuhele’s offerings. Event recap and more photos coming soon!
Judging by the turnout for the presentation at Inuhele in Atlanta, there’s a great deal of interest in The Mai-Kai’s refurbishment plans. (Atomic Grog photo)
It was a pleasure to share all the latest exclusive information on The Mai-Kai refurbishment plans with an enthusiastic audience. It was the first presentation on the first day, and the line to enter the “Jungle Room” stretched down the hall and into the lobby.
Mahalo to Jonathan and Allison Chaffin and their expert staff for the great event. And okole maluna to hospitality director Lucky Munro and Mai-Kai historian Tim “Swanky” Glazner for their help with the cocktails. The support staff at the presentation was also very gracious, helping us solve a few technical issues and get the event on track as fast as we could. We hope to see y’all next year!
Swanky pours the Black Magic while Hurricane Hayward handles the Barrel O’ Rum. (Atomic Grog photo)
Inuhele, which started in 2018 as the Atlanta Tiki home bar tour, means “cocktail journey.” So I thought it was only fitting to kick off the show by talking about my personal cocktail journey at The Mai-Kai. My fascination with the delicious drinks, and the Tiki revival in general, started there around 15 years ago and is still going strong. Go to The Mai-Kai Cocktail Guide to see the results of this journey.
Past presentations at The Hukilau and The Mai-Kai have included deep dives into the cocktails, the menu, and the restaurant’s historic rum collection. In 2022, we turned our attention on the blog to the massive renovation project, posting exclusive news and photos as work progressed. When the opportunity arose to share our insights at Inuhele, we jumped at the chance.
None of this would have been possible without the crucial cooperation and assistance of several key members of The Mai-Kai team who have be extremely helpful over the years with all of our coverage: General manager Kern Mattei and public relations director Pia Dahlquist. Also mentioned at the top of the presentation was the leader of the new ownership team, Bill Fuller, a founder of both real estate development firm Barlington Group and restaurant management group Mad Room Hospitality.
I thanked Fuller for having the vision to restore and reimagine The Mai-Kai, and for providing access and graciously answering all my questions as I continue to cover the most magical restaurant in the world.
Images from the title slide show three eras of The Mai-Kai: The 1950s, when the restaurant was built in a desolate area far west of the popular beachfront. A recent view from what is now a very busy Federal Highway. And a rendering by “Typhoon Tommy” Allsmiller of the planned event center addition, coming in the second phase of the renovations.
CHAPTER 1 – The Legacy
While most Tikphiles in attendance knew quite a bit about the 66-year history of The Mai-Kai, we couldn’t discuss the significance of the current renovations without a brief tour through the past. Opened Dec. 28, 1956, in the small Fort Lauderdale suburb of Oakland Park, The Mai-Kai became a local and national historic landmark in 2014.
The dining rooms were outfitted with authentic artifacts from Polynesia, along with much work by budding restaurant decor firm Oceanic Arts. Massive Tikis by legendary carver Barney West were installed in the early 1960s. Sadly, only one survives. But it’s due to be restored as part of the refurbishments.
The Mai-Kai’s Polynesian Islander Revue was the longest-running authentic South Seas stage show in the United States (including Hawaii) until the 2020 closing due to a roof collapse over the kitchen and back-of-house area. The show’s original bandleader, Toti Terorotua, came from Don the Beachcomber in Hawaii and continued to perform until shortly before his death in 2020. Inuhele guests were treated to the sounds of Terorotua & His Tahitians, his band from the 1950s, before and after the presentation.
A slide from the Inuhele presentation: The 1970 expansion increased the restaurant’s capacity from 350 to its current 450, plus another 150 in The Molokai. For the next five decades, The Mai-Kai could service more than 700 diners comfortably at any one time during the busy season.
Launched in 1962, the stage show is poised for a comeback under the leadership of Mireille Thornton. She started as a dancer, soon became the show producer and choreographer, then married owner Bob Thornton. The family, led by daughter Kulani Thornton Gelardi, remains part of the ownership team and will continue to run the restaurant and serve as its creative force.
The Mai Kai was already considered a landmark when it expanded in 1970. The $1 million project (see image above) included new dining rooms, lush landscaping of what is now the Tiki gardens, and the construction of the 7,000-square-foot back-of-house section that was compromised in October 2020. Also added were the kitchen’s rare Chinese wood-burning ovens, which were saved and will be relocated.
Also added: A redesign of The Molokai lounge using decor salvaged from the Marlon Brando film Mutiny on the Bounty (1962). The nautical theme extends to the entrance area and back of house. One of the bar’s signature features is windows that are covered in a constant faux rainstorm that adds to the illusion of being trapped in a turn-of-the-century seaport saloon.
The 1970 additions would be the last major construction project at The Mai-Kai until 2022. For the next five decades, the restaurant cemented its reputation as the most grand Polynesian palace built during the mid 20th century.
A slide from the Inuhele presentation shows the area damaged and later lost after the October 2020 roof collapse. Photos by The Atomic Grog (top) and The Mai-Kai.
CHAPTER 2: The Deluge
The Mai-Kai managed better than most during the early days of the pandemic in 2020. While indoor service shut down, cocktails and food were available to go, and the restaurant fully reopened after two months. But the old adage “when it rains, it pours” proved to be true (literally) when a massive storm hit in late October at the same time a pipe burst in a main sprinkler system line, leading to the collapse of the roof over the 1970s-era kitchen.
